University of Massachusetts Amherst

Search Google Appliance

Links

Paul Collins appointed to the editorial board of Law & Social Inquiry

Paul Collins, Professor of Legal Studies and Director of Legal Studies, was appointed to the editorial board of Law & Social Inquiry. Collins also published, along with Christina L. Boyd and Lori A. Ringhand, an article in Law & Society Review titled: "The Role of Nominee Gender and Race at U.S. Supreme Court Confirmation Hearings".

Abstract: We investigate an unexplored aspect of the U.S. Supreme Court confirmation process: whether questioning senators treat female and minority nominees differently from male and white nominees. Applying out‐group theory, we argue that senators will ask female and minority nominees more questions about their “judicial philosophies” in an effort to determine their competence to serve on the Court. This out‐group bias is likely to be exacerbated for nominees not sharing the senator's political party. Our results do not support racial differences, but they do provide strong evidence that female nominees receive more judicial philosophy‐related questions from male senators. This effect is enhanced when the female nominee does not share the partisan affiliation of the questioning senator. Together, these findings indicate that female nominees undergo a substantively different confirmation process than male nominees. We further find that this effect may be most intense with nominees like Justice Sotomayor, whose identities align with more than one out‐group.

News Type: 

  • Faculty News